Log in

No account? Create an account

Don't Eat With Your Mouth Full

Where can we live but days?

steepholm steepholm
Previous Entry Share Next Entry
Wasted on the Young
I'm sure this point has been made elsewhere, but since everyone from Eric Pickles to the Daily Mail (and even some Labour supporters) have taken to describing the pledge to abolish university tuition fees for English students as a "bribe", I'd just like to point out that, if you want to look at it that way, corporation tax cuts are a bribe, as are the triple lock on pensions, with free TV licences, bus passes, winter fuel payments, free prescriptions, etc etc. And the NHS, of course. Why get all hoity toity about it only when the young are beneficiaries? It smacks doubly of hypocrisy when most of the people flinging this word about were the beneficiaries of free university education themselves. (I've yet to hear of any of them offering to pay the money back.)

"Bribe" is the wrong word to use in all these cases. Free education is a recognition that we all benefit from having an educated population; the NHS is a recognition that we all benefit from having a healthy population; those who advocate tax breaks do so (in most cases) because they think it will benefit the economy generally. This isn't bribery, just enlightened self-interest.

You might even think of it as paying forward some of the benefits (bribes, if you will) that you received. Or do you think your parents were profligate fools when they bribed you for your love with food, shelter, money, toys? I've no patience with that view of the world, especially when it's so selectively applied.

Tangentially (as I noted on FB the other day), Greg Mulholland's father was on Any Answers on Saturday, arguing that students should be registered to vote in their parents' constituencies rather than the university towns where they live. That way, they won't be able to gang up on poor Tory and Lib Dem candidates like Sir Julian Brazier and, er, Greg Mulholland. Hilariously, he began by saying how much he welcomed the fact that the young had decided to vote this time. He just wants to make sure that their vote won't count.

Actually I wouldn't be at all surprised if some of the swing of conservative constituencies to Labour ones was because of young people unable to move out of their parents' houses, and therefore taking up space in, say, Kensington...

True, that.

We get that kind of Scrooge-like thinking a lot in the US from Republicans, that the poor are just layabouts who want handouts. Only it goes further here, because health care is treated this way, as a privilege that should be available only to those who take good care of their health themselves (and are lucky enough not to have anything complex happen to them).

If they're Scroogeness were evenly distributed I would have slightly more respect for them, but these are also the people who want tax breaks/cuts for themselves.

True. And am I alone in seeing something nauseating in reports that now all of Corbyn's Labour critics love him?

You're not alone - but don't worry, some of them are already bad-mouthing him again.